So I never really understood the whole Twilight phenomenon, and my husband just summed it up perfectly in a post on facebook. Since most of you aren't friends with him on facebook,I just had to share it here, it's too funny! It's a little long but I promise it's worth your time. :)
Written by Sita
So I gave it a chance--twice.
I actually tried reading the first book once. I'm pretty open minded and I enjoy a good book, so I thought, "why not?" I 'm comfortable enough with myself as a person--specifically as a man--that if I like something, I will stand behind it (ie. Muppet Babies is one of my favorite shows of all time).
The book started out fine. An average young-adult-demographic based book full of background informing, personality describing, and stage setting. Typical. Meyer definitely knows what she's doing. The story starts to pick up and Ol'Eddie boy is starting to be more than "The most beautiful creature" ever--he is faster than a speeding bullet and can stop out-of-control cars that are going to hit the main character of the story. Where the story goes down hill for me, is around page 200. The two of them start fighting over who loves who more. The conversation goes something like this:
What's her face: You don't really think you love me more than I love you
Vampire Super Model: Maybe
WHF: You know that's not true right?
White Vampire version of Tyson Beckford: It is true
Chick: No. I love you more
Dude: No. I love you more
chick: No you don't
Dude: yes I do
etc........
At that moment, I closed the book and prayed for forgiveness, never to read anything about them again. Life goes on.
Then they make a movie. Long story short, I end up renting it because my sister-in-law is in town and needs to be entertained (she's 8) and I did kind of want to see if the movie was better, I'll admit. Long movie short, another two hours wasted.
So after sampling the book and the movie I have to ask: why?
For example, this story is supposedly a love story between Ed and Bella. Fine. I got no problem with love stories. Even a little cheesiness is allowable. I'll give you a couple "I love you forever" s and some "You are the love of my life"s, but in moderation of course. So that's not necessarily my complaint (even though I know the story was based in Washington so that they could eventually kiss in the rain). My question is based around the sub-question, how does this story make sense to anyone? This love story between Bella and Ed is ridiculous.
Basically she is in love with him because (in a 16-year-old-valley-girl voice) "he's like the hottest guy ever." All she ever talks about is his face and his eyes and how they make her feel. That's why she wants to spend eternity with him. He's hot. She's basically a common-wealth Paris Hilton, but awkard, bright and down-to-earth. That makes a lot of sense.
Also she's supposed to be witty and intelligent. You know, the stereo type brunette who is generally a downer and makes a lot of sarcastic statements? You know, the one that's supposed to be down-to-earth and relatable? The one that 13-25 year-old girls are supposed to sit back and say that's me. Yeah, that same plain-Jane representative wants to spend eternity with a vampire--an undead, blood sucking, people eating, never sleeping, frozen cold vampire. It's not uncommon to hear people who won't kiss smokers because of the awful smell/taste. What do you think Ed's blood soaked breath smells like in the morning? Also what woman is going to want to snuggle Ed in bed? He's freezing cold. It's the woman's job to put her freezing feet on the man at 2 am and wake him up. Oh but wait, he'll still be awake. Who doesn't want a guy who constantly looks at them while you sleep? But, you're right, I forgot; he's hot. Bella's character is so confusing. She's supposed to be an outcast--not really offically in the in-crowd. And yet she is the most popular person in town. Everyone loves her. Make up your mind.
Let's not leave Eddie out of the discussion. Let's talk about why he loves Bella. Being the Vampire that has everything, why would he want Bella? Because she smells good. That's his answer. He is attracted to her because she drives him wild with her tasty smell. She's his favorite food. Now while I can sympathize with a man who likes good food, I don't see my self risking my life over Steak--possibly injury--but not my life. Neither would I ever marry a steak. But maybe that's because I'm not a "vegetarian" like Ed. Maybe if I gave up the meat, it would attract me so much that I would want to live and love it instead of eat it. How romantic Meyer. I guess the true way to a man's heart is his stomach.
Let's not leave out the fact that Ed is also possibly the ultimate creepy guy ever. He stalked Bella for months before he had ever spoke to her-- and he did this iin her actual room. Let's also not forget that, technically, he's a pedophile. A 100 year old man with a 17 year old, but I guess statutory rape doesn't count if you're "way hot." Twilight: giving old creepy men hope since 2005.
Anyway, it just seems strange to me that a book whose demographic is primarily young women would be about a century old sex offender who drinks blood falls "in love" with his favorite meal which happens to be the most confusing character ever written. So please, explain away ye faithful fans.
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
Twilight lovers read at your own discretion
Posted by Sita, Shalie, Kalia, and Vili at 9:20 PM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
10 comments:
Wow, Spencer and I loved reading this! Why I am a Twilight fan, I have to give Sita credit for his awe inspiring book analysis! Way to go Sita!!
I have never given Twilight a chance...ever! Nor will I ever! When I was serving in YW in Vegas, some of the leaders were reading it and suggested it to me. I said, "why not, right?" Then they said it was about a "vampire boy...blah, blah, blah...but it's good." Ummm...no. I don't have enough time during the day anyways, let alone to make time for a book about vampires. Thanks Sita. I don't always agree with you, but on this issue, I'm with you 100%.
Oh too funny...but I'm still a huge fan with no way of explaining why. :) Good summary though.
ha ha. yeah I have never understood the Twilight obsession. I read the first three books (actually I have yet to read the last chapter of the 3rd book). I didn't picture Edward as attractive and I agree on the creepiness. That's why I actually enjoyed the movie because it was portrayed better than I had it in my head. I guess I'm not much of a romantic!
I read the books and thought they were somewhat enertaining -- even though the grammar sucked (though Stephanie Meyers admits to not being a great writer, but more of a storyteller). Taken like that -- I thought it was a pretty good story (my imagination filled in all the gaps/inconsistencies). But I've read it and moved on to other things. I'm not dreaming of Edward -- and waiting for more...
Haha, I love it!! Sita is pretty funny!! I have to admit I loved the books, but I love his post. It's all true haha...
I did not read the books, but I do think the actor for Edward is pretty hot. I watched the movie I consider the series mormon porn.(not that mormon porn is bad) Meyer created a couple that want eachother so badly with such force even in naughty ways (yes even down to sucking your blood naughty)but they never can, for obvious possible deadly reasons. Edward is her sex magnet and she is what he has waited hundreds of years for etc.
I guess your right Sita...in our eyes it is the cow he wants to love and make out with instead of eat at In n out between two buns animal style. So I guess what this means is watch out for me if I am a vampire ..animal style all the way baby! And as it seems watch out for Sita also if he becomes a vampire....(Shay) And for all of those girls out there saying your husband is your Edward....is he really?
AHAHAHAHAHAHAA! Honestly one of the funniest things I have ever read. I love it! I've read all the Twilight books... never been an addict maybe just read them because they are, for lack of a better word... Entertaining. I agree with the creepiness of Edward and confusion with Bella's character. Don't get me started on the movie, let's just say it was "pretty". Great cinematography and a great soundtrack. Haha. Sita is effing hilarious!
Oh Sita I love you! haha I am a Twilight fan but that doesn't mean I can't appreciate your sarcastic hilarious point of view. Now go buy some Nerd "eggs" and calm yourself down.
Holy funny....that was AWESOME! I loved that and will be showing that to a few of my friends ;)
Post a Comment